Shelter Island, NY



Nestled at the end of a private, nearly mile-long drive winding through protected “forever green” land, Congdon’s Point is a rare and irreplaceable peninsula estate. Set on 2.1 acres, the property boasts approximately 443 feet of pristine Coecles Harbor shoreline, offering unparalleled privacy and stunning panoramic views of Reel Point and the Mashomack Preserve. This serene sanctuary provides the perfect blend of natural beauty and exclusivity.
Crafted with exceptional attention to detail, the estate showcases superior craftsmanship and the finest high-end materials throughout. Its unique location combined with thoughtfully designed living spaces creates an extraordinary opportunity for those seeking a one-of-a-kind waterfront retreat. Congdon’s Point truly defines sophisticated coastal living at its finest.





Shelter Island, NY
East Hampton Airport (HTO) 8.2 mi (13.3 km) away
Southampton Village Main Street 13.5 mi (21.7 km) away
Sag Harbor Village & Marina 5.1 mi (8.1 km) away
East Hampton Main Beach 11.3 mi (18.2 km) away
Montauk Point 23.7 mi (38.1 km) away

Every detail handled, so you don't have to.
We go beyond simply handing you the keys. Our concierge team is with you from booking to departure.
No hidden fees — our full concierge service comes standard with every rental.
Living Size 5,447 sqft
Reserving your villa with The Nightfall Group is the first step toward an experience shaped entirely around you, guided from start to finish by a team of dedicated local specialists.
You can send us your request straight from our website using the "Request Availability" button, or reach out directly via WhatsApp.
Once your request lands with us, our team will check availability without delay and come back to you with one or several proposals matched to what you're looking for.
Because our properties are in strong demand, we suggest booking at least 4 months ahead to lock in your preferred dates and villas. That said, thanks to one of the broadest portfolios of luxury villas, The Nightfall Group is often able to find outstanding options even on short notice.
For bookings made more than 90 days before arrival:
For bookings made within 90 days of arrival:
Security deposit amounts differ from property to property and will be shared with you when you book.
Payment is accepted by bank transfer only.
Check-in and check-out times can differ slightly from villa to villa. The Nightfall Group will always work to accommodate your schedule wherever possible.
On arrival: Check-in typically starts from 4:00 PM.
On departure: Check-out is typically set for 10:00 AM.
Our on-the-ground team works closely with you to shape a stay built around what matters to you, offering local know-how and managing your reservations from start to finish.
Among the services we can arrange:
Transportation
Private Staff
Reservations
Your Nightfall Group representative and concierge team remain available throughout your stay, from arrival to departure, taking care of the details so you're free to enjoy your time.
Rental Rates
Starting at $5,500 per night
Location
Shelter Island, NY
We will be with you shortly.





